The Second Generation of Georgia Planning

When the Georgia Planning Act was adopted in 1989, few local governments in Georgia had a comprehensive plan. Thus, much of the state began to undertake a thoughtful consideration of community needs and the future for the first time in the early 1990s. By mid-decade most local governments in Georgia had completed a comprehensive plan.

Georgia DCA planning rules only require a full plan update every 10 years. So, beginning around 2003, many local governments began the required update of their initial comprehensive plan. During the 10 years that passed from the adoption of the Georgia Planning Act to the early part of this decade, planning changed significantly across the U.S.

The concepts of Smart Growth, New Urbanism and linking land use and transportation strategies gained widespread acceptance. National organizations, federal, state and local governments began to accept that the prior decades of investment and development decisions were not sustainable. The private sector began to respond to a growing number of home buyers and renters who wanted living standards unique from a suburban home and commute. Mixed-use development became economically feasible in many areas. In the late 1990s, Post Riverside and the City of Smyrna began capturing planners, elected officials and the private sector’s attention.

During the past five years, most city and county governments in metro Atlanta have updated plans to the “second generation” of Georgia comprehensive plans. This is an important milestone. This second generation of planning has brought vast and significant positive changes to local development policy. Many counties, like Gwinnett, have produced plans that are truly cutting edge linking housing and transportation investments. These new local government plans have considered growth scenarios, fiscal impacts and rural land protection. Many cities, including Decatur and Atlanta, have undertaken planning to build livable neighborhoods with a diversity of housing, shopping and travel choices.

During the past two decades frenzied population and economic growth, largely a result of national migration trends, dominated metro Atlanta planning. Planners spent most of their time and effort processing rezoning applications, subdivision plats and site plans. And there continues to be major stumbling blocks that could undermine our planning and progress in Georgia. Georgia does not enforce rules to make local comprehensive plans consistent with zoning and development regulations. Therefore, zoning rules will not change automatically to enact the second generation of comprehensive plans. It will take years of ordinance revisions, rezoning changes, overlay codes and other actions to change the primary rules that implement our comprehensive plans.

Why will it take so long? At least two good reasons exist. First, local government attorneys, elected officials and planners in Georgia undervalue the substantial authority that they possess to guide growth. Almost 100 years of law in the U.S. and Georgia have provided authority for local governments to zone land and change rules to implement well-conceived growth strategies through a comprehensive plan. Local governments can uphold and enact many changes to improve our plan implementation. However, developers and attorneys spend many waking hours trying to undermine the reality of zoning law and the home rule authority of local governments in Georgia. Substantially more discussion and education is needed at all levels regarding the ability for local governments to implement plans.

Somewhere over the last decade many developers and builders became “speculators.” The market was flush with bank funding for new subdivisions and mortgages. But times have changed and the fallout from the recession and foreclosures could substantially alter future development patterns. Metro Atlanta currently has a record high inventory of available lots, and even with a 75-to-90 percent decline in building permits in metro counties, the inventory of lots still seems to be rising. Many developers are gambling that their projects will be ready when the market returns and local governments still appear willing to allow their communities to be the target for land speculation.

Eventually the market will soak up the current housing and demand will come back. But with aging baby boomers, fewer jobs and traffic congestion, there are many uncertainties about where demand will occur and for what housing products. Local governments must know three things: 1)what housing is currently built and available, 2) what housing will be needed and 3)what type of housing are current regulations going to allow.

Now is a good time for local governments in Georgia to show leadership and implement the second generation of comprehensive plans that we have produced. This includes seeking to truly understand and zone land to address community housing needs for seniors, young families and single professionals. And it means making the right public investments for transportation to maintain a strong Georgia economy for the long term.

Tags: , , , , , ,

One Response to “The Second Generation of Georgia Planning”

  1. Paul Soudi Says:

    I just would like to add that after Georgia Planning Act of 1989, the DCA chose the City of Villa Rica and prepared a comprehensive plan for it, to be used by other communities as an axample. That plan was Georgia’s first comprehensive plan, and I am glad I had the opportunity to have that historic document at my possession for a while and enforcing it.

    Following weaknesses pointed above, we might be in the need of our second generation of planning act, as well, that mandates local governments to address their critical issues in the plan and requires them to, truly, enforce it.

    The Second Generation of Georgia Planning article touched the heart of the matters and was very well-written. Thank you very much.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: